Where Are You From? Rochester or Detroit?
Blog on new HuffPost Detroit website claims the people of the suburbs need to get better acquainted with the city they call home.
When you travel far away from Rochester and someone asks you where you are from, what is your answer?
Do you say Rochester or Rochester Hills? Or are you from Michigan? Are you from Detroit?
In his first blog for the new HuffPost Detroit, which launched today, writer Toby Barlow says most of us in the suburbs identify our place in the world as being from Detroit — without having any idea of what Detroit is really like. It's time we all stop running away from Detroit, Barlow writes in "'Detroit,' Meet Detroit."
"If you're from Detroit, you've got to know it and be a part of it, embracing all of its opportunities, its troubles and its beauty," Barlow writes. "It is not just some idealistic dream, it's an economic necessity: The reason this is so fundamentally important is because – get this – it's the straightest path to getting your property values back. It's that simple. You may be from Berkley or Dearborn Heights or Beverly Hills or even Ypsilanti – it doesn't really matter how far out you go – but if you're in Southeast Michigan, you're from Detroit. It's your brand. So deal with it."
HuffPost Detroit has a mission of providing "an alternative to the knee-jerk narrative the national media love to tell about Detroit," founder Arianna Huffington writes in an introductory piece.
Patch and the Huffington Post are partners; we worked with HuffPost Detroit Editor Simone Landon last week while covering the GOP Debate at Oakland University.
That GOP debate fits nicely into this discussion of place: It was here in Rochester, yet most of the national media considered it happening in Detroit — even featuring photographs of the Detroit skyline in preview stories.
So, where do we live? In one of the Rochesters? In southeast Michigan? In Detroit?
Steve Kosinski
11:22 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
First, last & always, l KNOW Detroit, and AM a proud Detroiter!
Carolyn
11:48 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Metro Detroit. We are all in it together.
Susan Menko
12:36 am on Friday, November 18, 2011
I've attended university in Detroit for both bachelor's and master's and got to know some of the city by riding through it on a regular basis. I did not see the east side but the west side more often. Having said that...there is always more we can learn about the cities we live in. Even in the Rochester-metro area.
Mary Howarth
8:01 pm on Friday, November 18, 2011
It depends upon where I am as to how I describe my home town. If I am out of the country in a more rural place, I just say Michigan, in America. If it is a more urban area, I will say Detroit, Michigan. If I am in the States, I usually say Rochester, Michigan, just north of Detroit. As there is a Rochester in every state in the contiguous USA, it is necessary to declare the state also. I usually don't say Rochester Hills - people who have left the area do remember Rochester as more than just the 7 square miles of the political boundary.
Ruthann Bajorek
8:41 pm on Friday, November 18, 2011
My response is identical to what Mary Howarth posted. I have no problem with saying I'm from Detroit, but I prefer to be more honest, I suppose, since I don't know as much about Detroit as I should.